For Such a Time as This
Journal Entry: Sat Mar 22, 2008, 2:09 PM
I have been tracking a situation that came up with Brohawk and I would like to record one of my posts on the subject. Specifics on the situation may be reviewed on Brohawks page.
Here is the post:
I am amazed at how Dave has become the criminal in all of this. I'm not siding with Dave. I'm supporting truth.
Every artist has, at one point or another in his development, "copied" or referenced someone else's work. I'm a graphic designer/illustrator of 13 years and am now employed as an Art Director for one of the biggest art departments in the country and I still reference teachers like Michael Golden, Alan Davis, Jack Kirby, John Buscema, Walt Simonson and some new guys like Bruce Timm and, yes, even David Williams. I study their work and try to determine their process so that knowledge would improve my artistic voice. Its the same as in certain fine art schools where they try to "swipe" the masters to understand what they were thinking and utilizing that in their own work.
This is not what Skywarp was doing and he needs to know that. The guy literally took the art, manipulated it in photoshop and then called it his own. Thats called theft. (I sware I'm going to have to do a series of before and afters)
This is the kind of thing that will drive pro's like Dave away from sharing his work on sites like this.
There has never been a time like now, with the advent of the internet, where there has been so much free exchange of artistic expression and access to so much professional insight. When I was a kid I would have killed to send a message to John Buscema or Frank Frazetta and get an advice or critique from them. Dave has opened himself wide with step by steps and insight into his creative process. This is precious and it is our responsibility to protect it or we will lose it. Instead we assault these guys and I really think we're missing the point.
We are a community and we have to police ourselves and each other. All Dave did is hold Skywarp accountable. It's called integrity.
What all this has done is expose how many on deviant find this sort of behavior acceptable or minor and that is chilling to me. I know there are thieves out there but when you call yourself a "friend" on deviant, it should mean community and trust.
There are lots of folk out there with alot to offer there. I hope this sort of thing doesn't scare them away.
Devious Comments
If it is your intention to set a similar hue and cry after me you can save it.
Funny thing about integrity. People can be on opposite sides of an arguement and still be displaying integrity.
--
R2D2, you know better than to trust a strange computer!
Don't thank me for faves, browse a deviation by a stranger you like and fave it.
-See my response on Brohawks thread.
"If it is your intention to set a similar hue and cry after me you can save it."
-Who's being childish now? I thought we were all adults sharing ideas freely.
Hmm, maybe not.
Chill out man. This aint personal. Peace.
--
R2D2, you know better than to trust a strange computer!
Don't thank me for faves, browse a deviation by a stranger you like and fave it.
(Psssst... you're making a scene...)
Nothing to see here folks! Just two colleagues having a friendly conversation.
If they pull shit like this at the school I'm at, it's grounds for expulsion. If they do it in a professional setting where thousands to millions of people view their work, it's career ending.
Referencing is something every serious artist does. Lets face it, no one knows how to draw every single item in the world.
Studying other artists, breaking down their process and learning from it is something every serious artist does. It's a major part of the learning process, and it's helped me, personally improve leaps and bounds over just trying to figure things out for myself.
Cutting, pasting and manipulating things in photshop, and calling it your own is bullshit. It's like making your own hood ornament, placing it on a BMW and saying you made your own car.
Not only is it directly against what art is all about, they aren't learning anything.
These people should be banned, instantly and without hesitation. These people should be confronted by other artists. They are cancers in a community like this and should be removed. case closed
my point- i went to the page of the said offender in said debacle and saw that he clearly swiped several artists( tho some of his choices were rather dubious)-
the main thing i'm in agreement with is that he should give credit where credit is due- when i started downloading pencil scans from the web, i made sure to credit every penciller when i posted my inks- and though i have been given permission by several owners to sell prints or the originals of these pieces, i just can't bring myself to do it- they simply AREN'T MINE to do so-
and stealing someones designs and simply changing the gender-please!-try putting the black panther costume on a female figure, and publishing it as your own creation- see if marvels legal department doesn't leave you with a colostomy bag when they're finished with you
credit where credit is due- thou shalt not steal-simple, right?
--
......yeah, well, i'd rather have a gun and not need it, than need a gun and not have it......
I totally agree with you!
--
The only one there is at what I do!
--
The only one there is at what I do!
--
......yeah, well, i'd rather have a gun and not need it, than need a gun and not have it......
Previous Page12 Next Page